The Club Sandwich

  • Peggy Sue's Club
  • Sweet Marley's Club

The club sandwich.  Be it diner, deli, or cafe, chances are there’s a club sandwich on the menu.  Though the classic club is characterized by three layers of bread with sliced chicken, bacon, tomato, lettuce, and mayo, cut into triangles and held together by toothpicks, there are now an endless number of variations.  Just as the sandwich category is held together by a few specific guidelines, so is the club sandwich: as long as it has at least three layers of bread and has a need for toothpick security, you’re good.  This allows for a lot of creativity in the fillings, and a lot of great sandwiches.

Supposedly, the club sandwich made its debut at the Saratoga Gentlemen’s Club (get it?) at the end of the 19th century.  What is generally agreed upon is that it mimicked the double decker train cars that came into use in America around that time.

The sandwich pictured on its side is the Mickey Mouse Club from Peggy Sue’s that Corey ordered (turns out, he’s a big fan of club sandwiches).  This one had oven baked turkey, ham, bacon, tomato, lettuce, and american cheese.  Since I’ve already blogged about Peggy Sue’s, I won’t say any more, but I wanted to give an example of a club variation.

The second sandwich, from Sweet Marley’s in Fredericksburg, TX, was great and interesting for a couple of reasons.  First, the shop itself: Sweet Marley’s began when Marley was born.  Marley has an extremely rare disease, called Rhizomelic Chondrodysplasia Punctata, or RCDP.  There are currently less than 100 children living with the disorder, and most of them won’t make it past their second birthday.  Marley has broken every rule of RCDP, and is now two and a half years old.  Marley’s parents use the shop to pay for most of Marley’s medical bills, and also donate a percentage to other children with the disease.  What’s great is that most mornings, you can find Marley having breakfast in the cafe, and can see what an amazing little girl she is.  But on to the sandwich…

The Texas Club at Sweet Marley’s is quite a sandwich: three slices of texas toast, black forest ham, roasted turkey, cheddar, pepper jack, bacon, spring mix, tomato, and jalapeno mayo.  Now, I’ve had a good number of club variations, but this one was awesome.  For me, aside from the buttery texas toast and the sweetness of the ham, it was the pepper jack and jalapeno mayo that did it.  The contrast between savory and a little bit of spice was exactly what I wanted from this sandwich.

So as you can see, the club sandwich is pretty pervasive throughout the sandwich world, and could even have its own blog, considering all of the tweaks and personalizations you can do to it.  Keep an eye out for more clubs in the future.

One Comment

  1. Reply
    Alan Predolin June 2, 2012

    Glad to see your blog has lots of new sandwich experiences…
    Have 1 here in LA you should try.
    Victor and Helein just open a very cool vietnamese cafe on Sawtelle.
    Nongola

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *